Subscribe now to recieve updates on reviews

By AJ Jaffari

The cast of The Cottage. Photo by Scott Lasky.

What happens when a quiet weekend getaway turns into a revolving door of secrets, affairs, and utter chaos? The Cottage at Palo Alto Players embraces the timeless tradition of farce, delivering an evening filled with mistaken assumptions, rapid-fire revelations, and enough door-slamming antics to keep audiences on their toes. Sandy Rustin’s comedy takes inspiration from the classic British farces of Noël Coward and company, creating a world where the stakes are high, the emotions are exaggerated, and the consequences are delightfully absurd.

Set in a charming English countryside cottage, the story follows a tangled web of romantic entanglements that quickly spirals out of control as more characters arrive, secrets are exposed, and carefully laid plans unravel. Palo Alto Players leans into the play’s wit and silliness, allowing the audience to enjoy the ride without taking any of it too seriously—which, in my opinion, is exactly how a farce should be enjoyed.

As someone who generally enjoys farce, I had a great time with this production. These shows work best when you surrender to the absurdity, and The Cottage certainly gives you plenty of opportunities to do so. While there were a few moments where the plot slowed down for me, those lulls were quickly replaced by fresh complications, unexpected entrances, and enough comedic mishaps to keep the energy moving forward. It’s the kind of play that knows exactly what it is and isn’t afraid to lean into the chaos.


Steve Allhoff (Beau), Brandon Silberstein (Clarke), Lysander Abadia (Richard), Natalie To (Diedre), and Kate McGrath (Sylvia). Photo by Scott Lasky

The cast as a whole was strong, with each performer finding a distinct personality for their character and committing fully to the heightened style of the piece. Kate McGrath (Sylvia) and Steve Allhoff (Beau) were particularly charming, bringing wit and charisma to the center of the story. Their chemistry helped anchor the madness unfolding around them.

Brandon Silberstein (Clarke) once again proved why he’s such a reliable comedic force. Everything he does seems effortless, and his timing throughout the evening was impeccable. He continues to be one of those performers who can elevate a scene simply by being in it.

Another standout was Lysander Abadia as Richard, who was an absolute delight to watch. Abadia fully embraced the role and all of its increasingly ridiculous circumstances, committing to every moment with confidence and charm. His performance carried a wonderful sense of playfulness that fit perfectly within the show’s heightened world. Without spoiling too much, let’s just say he threw himself into the role in more ways than one (hint hint), earning plenty of laughs along the way.

Michelle Skinner (Marjorie) brought a wonderfully classic British charm to her role, delivering her lines with elegance and confidence while still finding plenty of humor. Natalie To (Dierdre) was another standout, particularly during her hysterical drunken moments, which earned some of the biggest laughs of the night. Together, the cast created a delightful collection of eccentric personalities that made the comedy land beautifully.


Steve Allhoff (Beau), Brandon Silberstein (Clarke), Michelle Skinner (Marjorie), and Kate McGrath (Sylvia). Photo by Scott Lasky

Behind the scenes, Katie O’Bryon Champlin guided the production with a confident hand. Farce requires precise timing and careful pacing, and this production largely succeeded in keeping the momentum moving while allowing the comedy room to breathe. As natural as a farce can feel, this one did, thanks in large part to her direction.

Kevin Davies’s scenic design was another highlight. The cottage itself felt cozy, inviting, and perfectly suited to the world of the play. The space provided an ideal playground for all of the entrances, exits, and comedic chaos that unfolded throughout the evening.

I also appreciated David Hobbs’s sound design, particularly the subtle details woven throughout the production. The small touches helped enrich the atmosphere without drawing attention away from the action onstage.


The Cottage is exactly the kind of evening that reminds us how much fun a good farce can be. Clever, chaotic, and filled with strong performances, Palo Alto Players has delivered an entertaining production that embraces the genre’s strengths while inviting audiences to simply sit back and enjoy the madness.


The Cottage runs through June 28 and tickets are available here.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Broadway with AJ and Sarah

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading